When is the consultation process concluded?
The consultation procedure under section 17(2) of the Employment Protection Act (KSchG) is deemed to have been concluded when the works council issues a final statement in accordance with section 17(3), second sentence, of the KSchG and this is attached to the notification. The procedure is also deemed to be concluded if the parties at the workplace agree that all attempts at reaching an agreement have been exhausted and the procedure is terminated. However, a formal declaration of conclusion is not required; what is decisive is whether the employer may reasonably assume that there is no longer any prospect of further, productive negotiations.
If no statement has been provided, the notification may be made in accordance with section 17(3), third sentence, of the German Employment Protection Act (KSchG) only if the employer can demonstrate credibly that they informed the works council at least two weeks before making the notification and if they set out the status of the consultations. The two-week period refers exclusively to the earliest possible date on which the notice may be filed, not to the end of the consultation procedure itself. A works council may shorten the procedure by issuing a final statement ahead of schedule, but may not block it beyond two weeks. If the notification lacks the mandatory information required under section 17(2), first sentence, of the KSchG, the consultation procedure has not been duly initiated. In this case, the employer cannot rely on Section 17(3), third sentence, of the German Employment Protection Act (KSchG), because the two-week period has not begun to run due to the lack of proper notification. The employer is not obliged to continue negotiations indefinitely if they have fully informed the works council and have made a genuine offer of open-ended consultations, but the works council fails to respond within a reasonable period.
A reconciliation of interests pursuant to Sections 111 and 112 of the Works Constitution Act (BetrVG) brings the consultation procedure to an end and is deemed to constitute the works council’s statement under Section 17(3), second sentence, of the Employment Protection Act (KSchG). This applies to a reconciliation of interests with or without a list of names, provided that it contains a sufficiently clear, comprehensive statement from the works council. However, the reconciliation of interests does not automatically replace all other requirements of the notification procedure; in particular, the notice of collective redundancy itself must contain all the mandatory information required under Section 17(3), fourth sentence, of the KSchG.