How is the sale of a business taxed?
The tax implications depend on the seller, the legal form of the company, the level of shareholding and the structure of the deal. A reliable assessment therefore requires an individual calculation.
Privately held GmbH shares
If a natural person has held a direct or indirect stake of at least one per cent within the last five years, the capital gain is generally recognised in accordance with Section 17 of the Income Tax Act (EStG). Under the partial income method, 60 per cent of the gain is taxable. Similarly, 60 per cent of the related expenses may, in principle, be taken into account. The effective tax burden depends on the individual’s tax rate, the solidarity surcharge, church tax and other circumstances.
Shares held by a corporation
If a corporation disposes of its shareholding, 95 per cent of the gain is generally excluded from taxation under section 8b of the Corporation Tax Act (KStG). Five per cent is treated as a flat-rate, non-deductible business expense. As a result, the tax burden at holding company level is usually significantly lower. However, the proceeds initially remain within the holding company. A subsequent distribution to the individual triggers further taxation. Furthermore, contribution procedures, lock-up periods and anti-abuse rules must be observed. A holding company is therefore not set up shortly before the sale solely on the basis of the 95 per cent rule.
Sole traders and partnerships
When selling a business, part of a business or an entire share in a partnership, Sections 16 and 34 of the German Income Tax Act (EStG) may apply. Tax allowances and preferential tax rates depend on personal and factual requirements. The sale of individual assets, on the other hand, is generally subject to taxation on an ongoing basis.
Asset deal via a GmbH
If the operating GmbH sells its assets, the profit is initially recognised by the GmbH and is subject to corporation tax and, as a rule, trade tax. If the remaining proceeds are subsequently distributed to the shareholders, a second level of taxation applies. From the seller’s perspective, an asset deal is therefore often less attractive from a tax perspective than the direct sale of shares.
Value Added Tax and Land Transfer Tax
Depending on the seller’s status, the sale of shares may not be taxable or may generally be exempt from VAT. An asset deal may be exempt from VAT as a transfer of a business as a whole if a viable business unit is transferred to an entrepreneur. If only individual assets are sold, VAT must be assessed separately.
Land or companies owning land may be subject to land transfer tax. In the case of a share deal, complex rules regarding shareholdings and attribution apply, which must be modelled at an early stage.
In a share deal, the shares in the company are sold. The company remains the owner of its assets and the contractual partner of its customers, suppliers and employees. For a natural person, the capital gain may be taxed in particular under Section 17 of the Income Tax Act (EStG). Where the seller is a corporation, Section 8b of the Corporation Tax Act (KStG) may be relevant. Historical liabilities remain with the company and are therefore allocated via due diligence, warranties and indemnities. In the case of shares in a limited liability company (GmbH), the contract must be notarised.
In an asset deal, the company disposes of individual assets and legal relationships. Contracts must generally be transferred individually, whilst employment relationships may be transferred by operation of law in the event of a transfer of an undertaking under Section 613a of the German Civil Code (BGB). The capital gain initially arises at the level of the company. A subsequent distribution may trigger a second stage of taxation. In return, the purchaser can select assets more selectively and obtain a new tax depreciation base. Land regularly triggers immediate land transfer tax, and the contract is subject to notarisation insofar as it covers real estate.
The tax structure should be finalised before approaching potential buyers. Once a Letter of Intent (LOI) has been signed, making significant changes to the structure is often more difficult, riskier or no longer economically neutral.